Skip to content

Side Judge

David Meslow: Side Judge Stats

85 games as a side judge (reg. season)7 seasons (2016–2026)Recent: Week 1, 2026

Also worked 73 games as a field judge (2015–20).

Plus 6 playoff and 3 alternate assignments (164 total on file), not counted in the numbers below.

2026 officiating data is available through Week 5 (full crews through Week 1). We'll add later weeks as soon as they're released.

Scoring

How high or low the games run

Games go under the total notably more often than the league average.

% Games Over the Total

39%

10.1 pts below league

league 49% · 85 priced games

Avg Total Points

42.1

3.5 below league

league 45.6 · both teams combined

Spread Outcomes

Who covers the line in these games

Mild lean visible in spread outcomes: interesting context, not a green-light edge.

Favorites Cover %

51%

2.1 pts above league

league 49% · 85 priced games

Home Teams Cover %

54%

5.2 pts above league

league 48% · home-vs-road tilt

Penalties

Accepted penalties per game, by type

Penalty rate a little above the league average.

Penalties / game

13.3

0.6 above league (12.7)

accepted, both teams

Penalty yards / game

107

1 above league (107)

4th-quarter flags in one-score games

1.76

0.09 above league (1.68)

per game, score within 8, overtime excluded

Gives the offense a first down

Defensive flags that hand over a new set of downs

Per gameThis crewvs league
Defensive pass interference1.14+0.11
Defensive holding0.85+0.09
Roughing the passer0.35−0.06
Unnecessary roughness0.680

Stalls the drive

Offensive flags that push the offense back

Per gameThis crewvs league
Offensive holding2.62+0.14
False start2.36+0.13

Season by Season

SeasonGOverFavsPenYds
202610%100%16.0148
20251443%57%13.2102
20241644%63%12.798
20231050%40%9.476
20221436%43%12.9102
20211644%40%13.8113
20161421%57%16.5142

Regular-season games in this position. Over % and Favs cover leave out pushes; penalties are accepted penalties.

Team Records with David Meslow

5+ games, most games first
TeamGamesW-LATS
PIT106-47-3
HOU84-46-2
WAS86-26-2
BUF74-32-5
CHI71-63-4
DAL74-32-5
GB75-24-3
NYG71-63-4
TEN73-43-4
DET63-33-3
JAX63-33-3
LAC64-24-2
Show all 21 teams
PHI66-06-0
ATL53-22-2-1
BAL54-12-3
LV51-41-4
MIA53-22-2-1
MIN53-23-2
NE53-21-4
SEA54-13-2
TB53-24-1

Straight-up and against-the-spread records in regular-season games David Meslow worked in this position. ATS leaves out games with no line.

Recent Games Worked

FAV covered · DOG covered · OVER hit · UNDER hit · PUSH

Questions

Do games David Meslow works go over or under?

Under, more often than average. In 85 regular-season games as a side judge since 2016 with a total, David Meslow's games went over 38.8% of the time, 10.1 pts below the league average of 49%. Pushes are left out.

How many penalties are called in David Meslow's games?

13.3 accepted penalties and 107 penalty yards a game, both teams combined, against league averages of 12.7 and 107.

Data: nflverse. Compared with the league average since 2015.